Baltar: Why? Because I've taken a life?
Number Six: It makes you human.
Baltar: Is it? Not conscious thought? Not poetry, or art, or music, literature? Murder. Murder is my heritage.
Season 2 of the hit series "Battlestar Galactica" begins with a blast; with the aftermath of the attempted assasination of Commander Adama. Writers David Weddle and Bradley Thompson have a lot to deal with, what with Starbuck back on Caprica and a crashed Raptor down on Kobol. On top of all that, it seems that the Cylons are back with another fleet ALREADY.
And so begins a season that rarely ever slows down, both to positive and negative effect. For fans of the first season, Season 2 functions as most second seasons do; it's longer, bigger, split down the middle, but not necessarily better. It's curious considering the theory I have developed after my many years of television watching; I believe that it's nearly a universal fact that every second season of a TV series is superior in almost every way to the first. The second seasons of Burn Notice, White Collar, Chuck, Doctor Who (arguably), The Office, Torchwood, and Covert Affairs were all the best of their respective shows. Some notable standouts from classic series include Remington Steele and Quantum Leap, the latter being one of my favorite season of television ever. Time and time again this rule has rung true, and yet this season of Battlestar Galactica gets bogged down from hecticity and too many plot elements, making it unable to reach the heights season 1 was able to reach. That's not to say of course these elements aren't great. This is still Battlestar Galactica we're talking about here, and every time I put in a disk, I knew I was in for a treat.
As mentioned earlier, the season begins in total chaos, and unfortunately remains in that state for the first four episodes of the season, which really feels like a miniature story arc all in itself. The season premiere itself is titled "Scattered" which is more accurate than one would realize, and summarizes exactly what it feels like to watch these episodes. The separation is borderlined painful to watch, and you can't help but long for the relationships and characters you've come to love return to normal life in the fleet. Sadly, this doesn't truly occur until the eighth episode. Having said that, there is certainly some interest to be found in the heart of the chaos.
When held as part of their own contained story, each of the three is still outstanding.
First off, we've got a team of crash-landed soldiers down on Kobol. Originally to be a simple scouting mission, a freak Cylon attack sent the Raptor transport hurtling to the planet's surface, stranding Chief Tyrol, Cally and Baltar and others alone on the surface. Considering this group contained two of my three favorite character's, you'd imagine I was the most drawn by that story.
After Cally's life is threatened, Baltar surprises the audience by stepping up to the plate and saving her life, putting two in the back of Crashdown's skull. He's as surprised as we are; this is a big step for him, yet another sign that the soul of Gaius Baltar truly is good. Incredible performances by Nicki Clyne and Sam Witwer help sell the scene, and for a moment, we really do think Cally might actually be killed off. Assuming she isn't a Cylon of course. Thanks to Baltar, she lives to fight another day, both spiritually, and literally. But I'll come back to that. The group is eventually rescued, but one never forgets what happened on Kobol, and the scars run deep among the survivors, forever to hide the secret of Crashdown's death.
Nicki Clyne may be a phenomenal actress, but she doesn't hold a candle to who I now consider to be the legendary Michael Hogan, who really gets to stretch his acting chops this time around as XO Saul Tigh. With Adama still in the sickbay, Tigh must control the Galactica all by his lonesome, made worse by the fact that he's without the help of President Roslin and CAG Apollo, both of which he's chosen to be thrown in the brig. This decision inevitably backfires when he declares martial law and the entire fleet turns against the Galactica. One cannot blame poor old Saul for his mistakes however; he's not built for command life, nor has he ever wanted to be. In a brilliant use of flashbacks, we learn about his agreement with Bill Adama that one day they'd run a ship together, with Bill as Commander and Tigh as XO. He knew from the very beginning he couldn't handle a command all on his own; one wonders why he even pushes on. The answer is of course the old ball and chain.
Ellen Tigh was introduced late in the second season as a survivor on another ship who used to be married to Saul before the attack on the colonies. Adama hid her from him for as long as he could, for fear for her potentially being a Cylon agent. Something she very well still could be for all we know, Baltar tested her blood but never truly revealed the actual results either way. With that in mind, Ellen is a negative influence anyway. From her first episode she's been many things, all of them bad. An Alcoholic like her husband, who she used to cheat on regularly, Ellen is easily one of the most despicable characters on the show. During Saul's time as Commander, she acts as Old Georgie, Worm-tongue, a demon under the guise of Jiminy Cricket. Leave it to a beautiful blonde to whisper sweet nothings into your ear, until one day those sweet nothings turn into power grabs and poor decisions. Saul would never see the fault in her ways of course; he's so blinded by love that he barrels his way through his four episodes as Commander with arrogance and imperception, desperately trying to contain the truth that the pressure is pulling him under. His recklessness costs him the defection of Apollo and Roslin, and the deaths of four civilians during a riot onboard a hostile supply vessel. A highlight of the first half of season 2, Tigh's temporary command of the Galactica will never be forgotten. The riot during the supply run takes place during the fourth episode, "Resistance", which has multiple meanings, as back on Caprica, that very thing is discovered by a lost Helo and Starbuck.
Having been abandoned by Sharon, the duo find themselves alone upon the strange Centurion infested world. After a brief stint in Starbuck's old apartment, the two happen upon a wild discovery; the existence of a Resistance movement upon Caprica by a band of tough survivors called the Caprica Buccaneers. One among their number is a leading figure named Sam Anders (Michael Trucco), who bares a striking resemblance to Dane Cook and ends up in a fling with Starbuck.
They have enough in common for it to make sense; they're both rebels, fighters and are easily set off, although Anders maintains more of a purpose to his life. His rebellion can't help but remind one of the guerilla tactics of the "Resistance" against Skynet in the Terminator franchise, but it matters not. Anders is actually the most welcome thing to come out of the second season as a whole, officially joining the cast for season 3. His genuine nature and kind heart is what attracts both Starbuck and us to him, and that's only solidified by his rescue of her from a Cylon "Farm" in the fifth episode. In it we also meet the addition of a new human Cylon model to the series; Simon. Originally masquerading as a human doctor, Simon is eventually revealed to be in charge of a facility which harvests human DNA and such, where they even go so far as to steal one of Starbuck's ovaries. It's creepy as hell, and we want nothing more than for it to be over. Nothing could be more of a welcome sight than Sharon, flying to the rescue in a gigantic Cylon Heavy Raider, destroying The Farm and saving the day. As she leaves, Starbuck gives Anders her Galactica pilot tags, vowing to someday return to save all the Buccaneers they're leaving behind.
This effectively becomes the second season's undercurrent story arc.
Back on Galactica, all hell has broken loose. Boomer has been assassinated, shot in the chest by a vengeful Cally. In a scene that I'll never forget, Boomer falls into her former lovers arms, Chief Tyrol, now fully aware of her Cylon identity, and completely confused as to his own emotions. Boomer's last words don't help much. "I love you Chief." Nice one Valerii.
So what's the last thing the crew of the Galactica needs? Oh, that's right, another Boomer! Sharon arrives with Helo and Starbuck in the Heavy Raider, and is immediately detained by an enraged Apollo. He has good reason, after all this is a copy of the woman who shot his father. Throwing all caution to the winds, Roslin continues forward with her plan from the last season to investigate Kobol for the Temple of Athena, which supposedly contains the coordinates to the lost colony of Earth. Using the "Arrow of Apollo" Starbuck found in the Caprica ruins, the coordinates are found, and a journey is plotted, and life seems to at last go back to normal for everyone. Almost everyone.

The primary story arc of season 2 is the pregnancy of Sharon Valerii. Sharon's love for Helo has led to her full betrayal of the Cylons, elevating her beyond the heights that Boomer reached in season 1 as far as interest level is concerned. But the true reason for her loyalty to the Colonial Fleet is her unborn child, a baby girl, a human-Cylon hybrid. Sharon and her pregnancy cause a great deal of unrest among the crew and Roslin's staff, providing creator Ronald D. Moore with a phenomenal opportunity to ask the big question once more; What does it mean to be human? First off, we wonder if Sharon could be considered human if she has Boomer's feelings and memories. She remembers having Boomer's relationship with the Chief, although it wasn't her who had it. When she and the Chief first interact, (they meet on Kobol), she literally embraces him with open arms. He of course is too confused and shocked to take it all in, and this results in a later feud between himself and Helo. Another interesting question is brought upon by the release of Cally Henderson from 30 days in a holding cell, her sentence for killing Boomer being nothing more than for "unlawful discharge of a firearm". The argument made is that you can't kill a machine. This is true, you cannot truly kill something that was never alive. But how do we define "living". If Sharon has the ability to create life, doesn't that make her in essence alive? These kinds of questions couldn't be asked in anything short of this and Terminator, and this series actually has found a way to surpass the groundwork set out by James Cameron and become what I believe to be the primary authority on human-robot morality. I have never seen A.I. or Blade Runner, so I can't be certain, but from what I've seen, this is undoubtably the deepest, most thought-provoking science fiction topic of them all, and Battlestar Galactica takes full advantage of that.
The innate distrust of Sharon Valerii comes to a head in one of the series' greatest episodes, "Flight of the Phoenix. In which a Cylon computer virus nearly topples the Galactica's security, leaving it open for attack. And attack is on its way, as an entire enemy strike force barrels its way toward the Colonial Fleet. This is also the same episode in which Chief Tyrol is attempting to rid himself of the demons brought upon by Sharon's return, and to distract himself, he sets his focus upon what Apollo deems a miracle; the construction of an entire new fighter.
This episode shows the true heart of the show, with virtually the entire crew eventually pitching in to build what is dubbed "The Blackbird". Cally and Chief especially shine in this one, reflecting the very values that the series represents. Diligence; unity; the human drive to never give up. They both work tirelessly to bring the Blackbird to life, and act as one combined tool in the creation of something great. Their teamwork inspires the crew and the audience as well, proving once again that among the darkness, psychology, and drama or the series, a light burns brighter than all the rest, ticking another box on what makes the series truly spectacular.
It is the Blackbird combined with Sharon's help that saves the fleet, sending a virus back through the Cylons and tearing down their defenses, turning their strike force into a shooting gallery. But even that doesn't
sway the crew to her loyalty, and once again she is locked away. Over the
course of Season 2, Sharon's story encounters many an obstacle, each leading to
more profound questions of their own. The midseason finale brings the existence
of another Battlestar into the story, Battlestar Pegasus. While at first
seemingly a blessing, the new ship actually brings more bad than good, with the
psychotic Admiral Cain (Michelle Forbes) becoming the series first real human
antagonist.This comes in to play with Sharon's story in a big way, when a
ruthless interrogator comes aboard and attempts to rape her. In a fit of rage,
Helo and Chief accidentally murder the interrogator, and their capture and
ordered execution nearly cause the clashing Commanders to go to war. It all
stems down to the attempted rape, which the Pegasus XO defends by saying
"You can't rape a machine." Which in itself is just as curious as the
rest of Sharon's situation.
The arc concludes in the latter half of the season, where
Sharon's baby girl is successfully born. It's always beautiful to see a birth
on film, and on television I have discovered, it is no different. Helo remains by her side throughout the entire affair, filled with a love he has so passionately displayed the whole season. I have officially decided that Helo is actually my second favorite character. I like his unchanging nature, his understanding of himself, and his sense of right and wrong. Equally impressive is his self-control, which actor Tahmoh Penikett plays with constantly. He's talented beyond belief, and I can't wait to see what he does with the character in Season 3. Unfortunately, believing the baby cannot be allowed to live
with her Cylon mother, Roslin makes the questionable decision of having the
child switched with one that didn't make it from another vessel. Sharon's
seperation from her child nearly drives her insane, while the baby (named
"Hera"), is given to the mother of the deceased child, unaware of the
true identity of Hera's mother. In what is truly a heartbreaking end to a
fantastic story arc, Helo and Chief scatter what they think is Hera's ashes
into space, the tiny particles floating peacefully away into the distance. I
suspect Hera and her mother will play an integral role in future seasons, and
that the decision to separate her from her parents will come back to haunt
Adama and President Roslin in earth-shattering ways.
This season's ultimate strength is its remarkable use of
character development. The writing staff wisely uses a variety themes in
telling the story, always presenting them through inter-personal relationships and questionable decisions from the cast. Leadership is a present theme throughout the series; the idea of holding yourself together because of those relying on you. Adama and Roslin experience this from an episode to episode basis, and this season adds Tigh's situation and Starbuck as well. Another idea frequently touched upon is civil unrest, where the public in the fleet responds to things we normally only see impacting the crew of Galactica. But above all else, the writing staff of this phenomenal series have a wonderful talent for tackling the subject of Love.
Overall one of the greatest exhibitions of love in the series is the relationship between Helo and Sharon. Sparks fly between Roslin and Adama, the latter of which has clear fondness in his eyes every time he sets his eyes upon her. They never actually get together, but I assume it's coming somewhere down the road. The Ross/Rachel "Will they, won't they" of the series is Starbuck and Apollo, who have seemingly always held reserved feelings for one another. Starbuck's connection to Sam Anders back on Caprica puts a damper on things, so at this point it's hard to tell whether or not they'll end up together.
But the romance I've always been particularly happy with is that of Billy Keikeya and Petty Officer "Dee" Dualla. For those unacquainted with the series, Dee is the Communications officer onboard Galactica, and she becomes smitten with Billy the moment she sees him. Billy, (played by Paul Campbell), is the personal aide to President Roslin, his first day on the job being the day the Cylons first attacked the colonies, back when she was merely the Secretary of Education. The bond between he and Roslin is strong, and he seems to be the only one to be able to truly read her emotions. He's the first one to notice she has Cancer, and ultimately is the most loyal member of the Presidential staff, staying by her side when Adama tries to arrest her. Paul Campbell plays the seemingly simple role with slight layers of complexion, as it's clear that, (like Roslin), Billy doesn't have anyone else. In a world where there's no home to go back to, and everything is truly changed forever, the lasting effects of the destruction of the colonies don't take a toll larger on anyone than Billy. The crew of the Galactica adjust because they're doing the same thing they've always done, which is be the military. The impact of the loss sustained by the near end of the human race obviously would be felt if we saw the lives of a normal family living on one of the other vessels. The closest the series ever gets to that is Billy. His entire family was lost during the Cylon attack, as well as his dog Jake. His daily life has now been reduced to doing nothing but being Roslin's aide, with no friends or family to go to. He virtually has no personal life, and his internal sadness is expressed in every possible opportunity by Campbell. He desperately wants more out of life, and doesn't see himself working in politics forever. While on Kobol in "Home", he's floored by the revelation that Roslin believes he'll become President someday. Billy Keikeya is one of my favorite characters by far, and I love every scene with him onscreen. He's entertaining, unique, and definitely interesting, all elements formed from a combination of fantastic writing and Campbell's performance. Because of his job, he's elevated to being one of the primary players on the series, even being one of the group who gets to enter the tomb of Athena.
The group is Starbuck, Adama, Apollo, Roslin, and Billy. For the enitirety of seasons 1 and 2 it was my perspective that that group specifically were the main characters of the series.
Billy's only personal connection beyond Roslin is that of Dee, illustrating the theme of love in an undeniably beautiful way. The attraction is genuine, and the romance is adorable. It could probably exist on any other kind of show, and is the only relationship thus far in BSG that is somewhat normal.
Once again, the realism of this series never fails to surprise me; the love between the two builds slowly, blossoming like a lone flower in the grim darkness present in the rest of the show. One especially wonderful moment is when Billy takes her on a date to forward observation lounge in season 1, where the stars that have become a grim reminder of their great losses can be seen as beautiful once again. It's there that the two have have first pure romantic scene, and is a breath of fresh air for the gloomy world of BSG. The combination of his loneliness and love is what inevitably propels Billy to finally propose. Little is he aware of a lasting attraction between Dee and Apollo, which is why she turns him down. This devastates Billy, a feeling amplified by the later discovery of the two on a date together. What follows is potentially the saddest moment in the series run so far, as the lounge where the date is taking place is overtaken by terrorists demanding the delivery of Sharon; their psychotic leader blaming her for her own husband's death. When negotiations go wrong, Billy sacrifices himself to save Dee's life, taking a bullet in the chest and subsequently dying. He gets no last words, dying heartbroken and betrayed, a wound salted even further later on when Dee and Apollo get married. It's the only episode of the series to make me shed a tear, and was done so well, I can't complain that he's gone. I will always miss the quirky smile of Billy Keikeya, and he'll always share a place in my mind as one of the greatest things to come out of Battlestar Galactica.
Season 2 is full of so many things, from the discovery of a map to Earth, to the building of the Blackbird. Three more Cylon models are revealed, and we learn about existence of another Battlestar. From brilliant concepts like Resurrection ships to smaller, experimental episodes about a documentarian filming the daily life of the Galactica crew, the season has been chock full of interesting and powerful story elements. But there's one thing that makes this show great. One thing that reminds me why I keep watching.
This season belongs to Gaius Baltar.
The breakout character from Season 1 never fails to disappoint with the geniuses behind the writing of the series giving him more to do than ever before, his role becoming absolutely pivotal as the season progresses. Actor James Callis continues to both amuse and amaze, bearing the widest range of emotions I've seen from an actor in quite some time. I know the character of Baltar was present in the original series, but I honestly cannot imagine anyone else playing the role than Callis, who gives an unforgettable performance that's worthy of every bit of praise and all kinds of awards. He's charming and aloof at the same time; remaining both despicable and lovable while doing it. Just as in Season 1, any time he tries to cover up his possible insanity it's absolutely hilarious. Quite frequently, Six will try to converse with him while he's talking to someone else, resulting in Baltar attempting to talk to both parties with the same sentence, which literally feels like improv. It's fascinating that the topic of Six inside his mind can be the show's comedy outlet. If the series has any kind of comic relief character, Baltar is definitely it. No one else comes anywhere close. But as always, he's presented as a troubled and conflicted individual, and even in his worst moments, we find ourselves rooting for him anyway. Callis never crosses the line into true "Draco Malfoy" territory so-to-speak. Anytime his personal story moves towards something vile, he and the writers inject the appropriate amount of forgiving qualities to allow us to look past the
darker shade of Gaius Baltar.
In season 2, Baltar acts more of a medical doctor and scientist than ever before. No longer confined to his lab and the "Cylon detector", the seasons developments place the cast in need of his services, whether they like it or not.
darker shade of Gaius Baltar.
In season 2, Baltar acts more of a medical doctor and scientist than ever before. No longer confined to his lab and the "Cylon detector", the seasons developments place the cast in need of his services, whether they like it or not.
After returning to Galactica from his stint on Kobol, Baltar is given the responsibility of determining whether or not Chief Tyrol is a Cylon; an assumption drawn by Colonel Tigh based on the fact that the Chief and Boomer had previously been in a relationship. The scene that follows is one of the greatest examples of Baltar's brilliance, as he instead poisons the Chief in order to force Boomer to reveal how many Cylons are undercover on the Colonial fleet, to which Boomer eventually shouts, "Eight!" In order to draw out the revelation of the Cylon identities, the writing team uses Baltar's forgetfulness as a plot device, for it's only after he injects the Chief with the antidote that he realizes he could've asked Boomer who the agents are. Any other character would have asked immediately, but Baltar has too much a care for human life than to risk losing the Chief. His forgetfulness and his compassion come colliding full force in the scene, and it shows once again the strength of the character. It's especially a treat since we rarely get to see Callis play with compassion on screen. And so it's a further delight that we get an even better taste upon the arrival of the Pegasus mid-season, for onboard is none other than a living and breathing Six. She was undercover before under the name "Gina", and now has been beaten and raped by most of the Pegasus crew. He slowly nurses her back to health, declaring his love for her, and she in return provides information that he passes along to admiral Cain. That is of course until he helps Gina escape and she shoots Cain in the head. Since I absolutely despised Cain, I was of course ridiculously happy. Baltar spends the remainder of season 2 assisting with Gina's hiding on Cloud 9; the gigantic dome-covered terrarium ship at the center of the fleet.
Now we have arrived. This is the moment, the most profound scene in season 2, and possibly the best scene in the series so far. Episode 13: Epiphanies.
At last, President Roslin's cancer attacks with earnest, leading to her hospitalization under Dr. Cottle's care. Of course, in the case of the Presidency, the job will fall into Baltar's hands upon the case of her death, which all the characters know is imminant. During the course of this episode, the character of Gaius Baltar goes through the most remarkable metamorphosis, when the fate of not one, but TWO lives rest in his hands.
On her deathbed, Roslin's final wish is for the Cylon baby of Sharon and Helo to be aborted, a feat that she believes must be performed to save the future of the human race, as the baby is an unknown factor that has the potential to destroy everything she's worked to save. Meanwhile Baltar visits Gina aboard Cloud 9, where he attempts to seduce her, but she bites him in response, which she follows with saying she's sorry, but she's not ready. She then tries to tempt him to give up on siding with humanity, and use his upcoming Presidency to convince the fleet to turn against the military and let the Cylons find them and take over. Then one of the best moments in the series occurs.
Baltar touches his hand to his mouth, and holds it before him.
He stares at his hand, the fresh blood shining upon his fingertips, and for the first time, he truly accepts his humanity. He then turns to Gina and says the following line.
"No. No. I am not who you think I am. And I will not be responsible for the destruction of mankind."
Perfection.
Epiphanies presents Baltar's scientific mind in a way that no prior episode had ever accomplished. Throughout the episode, he can be seen drawing pictures of hexagons and octagons, some of which overlapping, and for awhile, the drawings are nothing more than random sketches. It isn't until after his return to the Galactica that we learn what has been going through the troubled Doctor's mind. As it turns out, Sharon's unborn child carries no blood type, an Amalgam, making its blood compatible with any other human being.
By the end of season 2, Baltar has won the Presidential election against Roslin; winning votes under a campaign of hope. An isolated planet capable of providing a new home for humanity has been discovered by pure accident, and he uses this discovery to his advantage, promising a fresh start that is very real, as opposed to Roslin's open dreams of finding Earth. After his triumphant victory, Baltar decrees the planet to be dubbed "New Caprica", and immediately orders that a colony be established. All seems well. In the first few days of their occupation however, Gina activates the warhead and commits suicide, destroying all of Cloud 9. It is a heartbreaking scene, and a shock to behold, the glass dome bursting into a thousand pieces and floating off into space. Then the series shocks you with another insane development by fast forwarding 3 years, where Baltar has become a lazy playboy abusing his power. Starbuck and Anders are married, as are the Chief and Cally, who is beyond pregnant. The planet is surrounded by the orbiting Battlestar's, where Adama is seeing less and less of a purpose guarding against Cylons that may never find them, and Apollo has become the overweight commander of the Pegasus.
If things weren't different enough already, in the season's last minutes, the Cylon's jump into orbit and invade New Caprica. Realizing the fight is pointless, Adama and Apollo escape with their Battlestar's, vowing to return to save the survivors left on the planet below.
With that, the season wraps, in arguably the biggest cliffhanger I have ever seen. Season 2 was full of intriguing elements, and while it slightly falls short of Season 1's greatness, it still holds up as a worthy successor, and continues in full stride Ronald D. Moore's phenomenal reboot.

























